Home » Uncategorized » Awesome pink sparkles have something for everyone

Awesome pink sparkles have something for everyone

If you identify as a girl, assigned female at birth, and you like the colour pink, you like wearing dresses and sparkly things, that’s awesome. But if you are a boy who likes pink sparkly things that’s also awesome.

It’s not a case of saying, let’s break everything down so that there’s nothing, so there’s no meaning in anything. It’s a case of opening it up so everybody can have access to everything.

These are comments from CJ Atkinson, author of the new book Can I Tell You About Gender Diversity? They are quoted in a promotional article in the The Guardian , which explains that the book is “being introduced into some [British] primary schools as a resource for children, parents and teachers, and claims to be the first book to explain ‘medical transitioning’ to children as young as seven.” The article comfortably notes criticisms of the book from right wing sources. It adds:

The 60-page booklet is the latest in the Can I Tell You About …? series of books published by Jessica Kingsley Publishers which are designed to offer a simple introduction to sometimes complex and challenging issues, including adoption, autism, depression, eating disorders and ME/chronic fatigue syndrome.

The book is therefore part of a continuing push to normalise transgender identity and conceal its elite-driven origins and its ideological underpinnings.

Like many if not most people viewing this article, I do not expect to read the book. The article itself is of interest, though, as a stand-alone item, particularly the comments quoted above from Atkinson. They could be read as progressive in intent: the first sentence designed just to soothe traditional-minded parents, and the rest a call to free both girls and boys from any kind of sex-stereotypic pressures.  Or they could be read as articulating the conservatism of trans ideology: pinkification is a free choice females make, and something to celebrate; “access to everything” only means access to the alternative stereotype; females remain forever handcuffed to femininity, and males to masculinity.

So, is the message in these quoted comments progressive or conservative? How about “progressive” and conservative. Rather than wonder what exactly Atkinson had in mind, it is more useful to see the article as continuing the mass media tradition of appealing simultaneously to multiple audiences around the issue of transgender, to offer something for everyone. Left-liberals who still feel some uneasiness about the stereotyping inherent in trans ideology are soothed with vague suggestions that all is well. More traditionalist readers are assured that this strange new trend does not really threaten their core values.

 

 

 

 

Advertisements

1 Comment

  1. Reblogged this on aunt polly's rants and commented:
    Fuck the color pink for girls & “sparkly things”. I hated the color pink when I was a little girl & refused to wear it. I wouldn’t wear pink until just a few years ago when my cousin got breast cancer & I started wearing pink “in support” & I found out that my mother was right, pink really IS my color. (& all the pink hunting camo helped, too)

    But why shouldn’t boys like “sparkling things”? Haven’t anyone watched old westerns? The sparkly guns & spangles on Roy Rogers’ outfits? Or how about an old movie & the sparkling diamonds on a man’s tux? Or the sparkling chrome on a Harley-Davidson? Why are “sparkly things” only for girls? That’s BS. Even in the 1960 & 70’s, men dressed up in sparking clothes & had long hair. Doesn’t anyone remember?

    & why are trucks & trains only for boys? This whole trans narrative is patriarchal in the extreme.

    I was always a tomboy & I grew in to a curvy, feminine woman who could hang with the guys & hunt & fish & curse & drink but still liked to keep a clean house & cook & sew & dress up like a babe cuz why the fuck not. It’s not either/or when it comes to “gender” . I am a woman. I like doing so-called “boy” things & I like doing so-called “girl” things because when push comes to shove, they’re all just fun ACTIVITIES.

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: